Ice Makers
10 Best Ice Makers for Either reservoir or water line (2026)
Ranked by our scoring engine based on real product data and feature analysis. Optimized for this specific use case.
Top 3 at a glance
1
Best OverallSilonn
Silonn Countertop
Best for: bullet cylinder ice with enough for a family or small gatherings
25/25
Why this pick
Manual fill models require you to pour water into a reservoir. The Silonn Countertop Self leads because it delivers bullet cylinder ice with enough for a family or small gatherings — exactly what this ranking prioritizes.
Bullet cylinder iceEnough for a family or...Quiet operationEither reservoir or wa...
2
Runner-UpAntarctic
Antarctic Star
Best for: bullet cylinder ice with enough for a family or small gatherings
20/25
Why this pick
The Antarctic Star Countertop takes a different approach: multiple ice sizes or modes (pick the convenience you care about most). It also brings refill the water reservoir manually (select the option that suits your setup).
Bullet cylinder iceEnough for a family or...Multiple ice sizes or ...Refill the water reser...
3
Also GreatCOWSAR
COWSAR Countertop
Best for: bullet cylinder ice with enough for a family or small gatherings
20/25
Why this pick
The COWSAR Countertop Portable takes a different approach: smart controls (pick the convenience you care about most). It also brings refill the water reservoir manually (select the option that suits your setup).
Bullet cylinder iceEnough for a family or...Smart controlsRefill the water reser...
4
#4 PickNewair
Newair Bullet
Best for: bullet cylinder ice with enough for a family or small gatherings
20/25
Why this pick
The Newair Bullet Ice differentiates with compact & portable design (pick the convenience you care about most).
Bullet cylinder iceEnough for a family or...Compact & portable designRefill the water reser...
5
#5 PickFRIGIDAIRE
FRIGIDAIRE Gallery
Best for: chewy nugget ice with enough for a family or small gatherings
18/25
Why this pick
The FRIGIDAIRE Gallery Countertop differentiates with chewy nugget ice (choose the texture that best suits your drinks).
Chewy nugget iceEnough for a family or...Self‑cleaning cycleRefill the water reser...
Why this pick
The Igloo Self Cleaning differentiates with chewy nugget ice (choose the texture that best suits your drinks).
Chewy nugget iceEnough for a family or...Self‑cleaning cycleRefill the water reser...
7
#7 Pickecozy
ecozy Countertop
Best for: chewy nugget ice with enough for a family or small gatherings
13/25
Why this pick
The ecozy Countertop Machine differentiates with chewy nugget ice (choose the texture that best suits your drinks).
Chewy nugget iceEnough for a family or...Self‑cleaning cycleRefill the water reser...
8
#8 PickGoveeLife
GoveeLife Countertop
Best for: clear or gourmet cubes with enough for a family or small gatherings
13/25
Why this pick
The GoveeLife Countertop Portable differentiates with clear or gourmet cubes (choose the texture that best suits your drinks).
Clear or gourmet cubesEnough for a family or...Self‑cleaning cycleRefill the water reser...
9
#9 PickhOmeLabs
hOmeLabs Countertop
Best for: clear or gourmet cubes with enough for a family or small gatherings
13/25
Why this pick
The hOmeLabs Countertop Ice differentiates with clear or gourmet cubes (choose the texture that best suits your drinks).
Clear or gourmet cubesEnough for a family or...Self‑cleaning cycleRefill the water reser...
10
#10 PickGE
GE Countertop
Best for: clear or gourmet cubes with enough for a family or small gatherings
12/25
Why this pick
The GE Countertop sidetank differentiates with clear or gourmet cubes (choose the texture that best suits your drinks).
Clear or gourmet cubesEnough for a family or...Smart controlsUse a detachable side ...
Not sure this is your top priority?
Take our 60-second quiz and we'll rank all ice makers based on YOUR specific needs.
Take the full quizMore ice makers roundups
As an Amazon Associate, Decision Widget earns from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are subject to change.